Se Habla Español
Lines are Available 24/7
Se Habla Español
Se Habla Español
Lines are Available 24/7
Se Habla Español
⭐ 4.9 Rating · 600+ 5-Star Reviews · 5,000+ Clients · Florida Bar No. 0085615 · Statewide Service
Florida probate beneficiary disputes are conflicts between or among heirs, devisees, and the personal representative during estate administration. Common categories: will contests, accounting objections, distribution disputes, homestead questions, elective share claims, and surcharge actions against the PR. Most disputes proceed in the probate court where the estate is being administered, governed by Chapters 731–735 of the Florida Statutes.
The most common disputes are: (1) Will contests on capacity or undue influence grounds; (2) Personal representative removal for breach of duty or non-performance; (3) Accounting objections — disputing PR’s reported transactions; (4) Distribution disputes — disagreements over specific bequests vs. residuary shares; (5) Homestead disputes — whether real property qualifies as exempt homestead under Fla. Stat. § 732.401; (6) Elective share disputes by surviving spouses under Fla. Stat. § 732.201; (7) Family allowance and exempt property disputes (§ 732.402–.403); (8) Creditor priority disputes; (9) Surcharge actions against the PR personally.
Most disputes resolve through one of four paths: (1) Negotiation and family settlement agreements — beneficiaries reach a compromise documented in a stipulation filed with the court; (2) Mediation — Florida circuit courts routinely refer probate disputes to mediation before trial; (3) Evidentiary hearings in the probate court — used for narrowly defined issues like PR removal or accounting objections; (4) Full trial — for contested will contests, surcharge actions, or homestead determinations. The 2d DCA recently affirmed a contested homestead determination in Schiro v. Elliott, No. 2D2025-2366 (Fla. 2d DCA May 29, 2026).
Yes — and it’s common. Sibling disputes are among the most frequent probate cases we handle. Typical scenarios: (1) One sibling who served as PR is accused by others of self-dealing or favoritism; (2) Siblings dispute the validity of a will that favors one over the others (often based on undue influence claims); (3) Siblings dispute whether a parent had capacity to execute estate documents during cognitive decline; (4) Siblings disagree over distribution of items with sentimental value not specifically bequeathed. The court hears these disputes as it does any other beneficiary action.
A family settlement agreement (FSA) is a written agreement among all beneficiaries (and sometimes the PR) resolving disputes without continuing litigation. FSAs are favored by Florida courts because they reduce court time and let families self-determine outcomes. Typical contents: (1) Modified distribution scheme that all signatories accept; (2) Release of claims against the PR and other beneficiaries; (3) Acceptance of an accounting on stipulated terms; (4) Agreement on disposition of specific assets. Properly executed FSAs are binding on signatories and enforceable in probate court.
Costs vary widely with complexity. Typical ranges: (1) Demand-letter and pre-suit negotiation: $1,500–$5,000; (2) Filing a petition with limited motion practice: $3,500–$10,000; (3) Cases settled at mediation: $15,000–$50,000; (4) Cases requiring evidentiary hearings: $25,000–$75,000; (5) Full trials with expert witnesses: $75,000–$200,000+. Florida courts have discretion to allocate fees under Fla. Stat. § 733.106, which can shift fees to or from the estate depending on who benefits from the litigation.
Generally no. The PR owes a duty of impartiality to all interested persons under Fla. Stat. § 733.602. Open partisanship by the PR is grounds for removal under § 733.504. However, a PR is required to defend the will being probated against contests, which can put the PR functionally on the side of will beneficiaries against intestate heirs. PRs who find themselves in a true conflict often resign or seek court guidance through a petition for instructions.
Typical timelines: (1) Family settlement agreements: 30–120 days if all parties cooperate; (2) Contested accounting objections: 4–9 months; (3) PR removal petitions: 4–12 months; (4) Will contests on undue influence or capacity: 12–24 months; (5) Full surcharge actions with damages calculations: 18–36 months. Mediation typically occurs midway through a contested case and resolves a majority of probate disputes before trial.
A caveat under Fla. Stat. § 731.110 is a written notice filed in advance by an interested person (often a potential will contestant) requiring the court to give them notice before admitting any will to probate. The caveat alerts the court that someone may want to contest, preserving the contestant’s opportunity to object. Caveats are sometimes filed by adult children who fear being disinherited or by ex-spouses who anticipate disputes. The caveat lasts up to 2 years and can be renewed.
Case citations verified against CourtListener. This page is general information about Florida probate litigation and is not legal advice for your situation.
See the complete Florida probate guide — administration, claims, contests, accounting, and mediation.
Managing Attorney, Zoecklein Law, P.A. · Florida Bar No. 0085615 · Probate, Trust Litigation
